| User | Rating | Min. Age | Adults Too | Comment |
| ERPriest | 9 | 8 | Yes | Our boys LOVE this game, and we have had great success introducing it to other families. The cards are a little confusing at first, but by the second game when everyone begins to understand the cards and the flow, things move along and are a blast. |
| blan86 | 8 | 8 | Yes | Great group game. There have been times that during some group camping trips, that the kids are constantly huddled around a table or in a tent playing this. |
| davebo | 8 | 8 | Yes | This is my most played game for '06, and that's entirely because my kids love it. My 7yo girl even likes it. |
| Jatoha | 8 | 8 | Yes | The kids love this one. Eight year needs some help, but does pretty well. This game involves shooting at each other and drinking beer, so keep that in mind if you'd be bothered by that. |
| Shade_Jon | 8 | 9 | Yes | I found it too random as an adult, but kids age 9 or older will probably enjoy shooting each other and trying to guess who's the deputy and who's the outlaw. Playing the sheriff or renegade is probably somewhat less fun.
The game uses beer cards to heal people, which might make you pause before handing it to some kids. |
| guantanamo | 7 | 9 | Yes | |
| lankyengineer | 7 | 9 | Some | |
| mentis | 7 | 8 | Some | This is a game playable by children and/or adults. However, children tend to 'overtalk' the game, which can dampen the game if adults are also playing. |
| The Unbeliever | 7 | 12 | Yes | Mature gunfighting/western themes. |
| boltongeordie | 6 | 9 | Some | Not for younger kids. The complexity, downtime, occasional lack of control and elimination all require a level of maturity to deal with. I think older kids may get some fun out of it but there are other, better games for them. Europeans won't mind the theme but ironically (given the setting) those in the US may. |
| Elden | 6 | 10 | Some | This game is about shooting at people and drinking beer to heal yourself. The gameplay is interesting and we play a slightly modified version of the game that we enjoy. For me, I would love the game to be translated to a different theme and have the game mechanics preserved. |
| wkusau | 6 | 11 | Yes | The mystery of who is who sometimes doesn't last long but shooting your big brother is always fun. |
| LostDice | 5 | 12 | Yes | Adults have can even have a hard time with the rules. |
| Norwood | 5 | 12 | Yes | Both on the rules complexity (which are confusing at times with all the different symbols on the cards) and the subject matter (shooting each other up and drinking beer to heal yourself), I'd be a little wary about playing this with kids much younger than 11-13. |