| User | Rating | Min. Age | Adults Too | Comment |
| flieger | 10 | | | This one was quite a hit for a long time. Whenever I play this I do some "role playing" with the pirate. The kids love it. There is always some excitement and lots of laughter. With the "advanced" variant this game can become quite challenging for youngsters. The bits, in true Haba tradition, are wonderful to look at and touch. This game is a must-have for families with young children. |
| jcarvin | 8 | 4 | | This is especially popular with the boys, it's about Pirates after all. The game is very simple, get games and avoid the pirate. |
| shawndumas | 7 | 6 | Some | It's HABA which means great game bits! Good kids game. Pre-teens and teens are not likely to enjoy. No half naked women, gore, cursing, or morbidity. |
| 1wif | 6 | 5 | Some | Meh. It has provided some fun family game sessions, but it never gets asked for, and we haven't yet lost a jewel, by any family member, back to Pete. I don't think our memories are very good either, it's just too simple. But the role-playing in it is fun. |
| shumyum | 6 | | | My kids have enjoyed it, but it has not given much of a spark. |