| User | Rating | Min. Age | Adults Too | Comment |
| cagriggs | 8 | 6 | Yes | My son enjoys this game. It has a great theme for kids and is a lot of fun to work together to try to find the ghost. That said, my six-year old is not ready to play as the ghost yet, which he wants to do, and the game can drag on a bit and we have to work to keep his interest. Still, we have enjoyed the game and I expect that enjoyment to go up as my son gets older and my younger sons reach the age where they can join in as well. |
| tiggle | 7 | 8 | Some | My 8 year old daughter likes this game, but has a hard time managing all the cards. She's won a couple of times as the ghost, but usually gets herself cornered and frustrated. She also has a tendency towards self-damaging table-talk. This is not a good game for overly chatty types and it does take some concentration at points. It's something we only need to play occasionally. |
| peacmyer | 6 | 3 | Yes | Some will like it, others not. Two adults plus patient 6+ kids probably works best. |
| wkusau | 6 | 10 | Some | I think it is pretty hard for kids under 10 to play well and enjoy the games. |
| Randy Cox | 4 | | | Knowing what a great game Scotland Yard is for older children, I tried this one out with a slightly younger kid (10ish), expecting great things. But it somehow just is not much fun. |