| User | Rating | Min. Age | Adults Too | Comment |
| jcarvin | 10 | 8 | Some | The game is pretty simple and should be easily picked up by older kids and adults will enjoy it too so long as they're not looking for anything too indepth. |
| boltongeordie | 9 | 6 | Yes | This is ideal. A light adult game with a fair bit of randomness and lovely design (good plastic pirates which work like 'action points' and some solid chits in a good holder). Nicely themed and with plenty of variety (including a variable board), if your kids are old enough to sit still at a table for an hour they will find themselves interested and entertained. |
| fsumarc | 9 | 8 | Yes | A fairly light game with a theme everybody loves. It's an easy game to give a brief explanation and then start the game and teach as you go. The components in this game are wonderful. There's lot's of dice rolling and players can ham it up with pirate talk and such. This game has gone over well in every session we have brought it out. Mixed ages and all. |
| Thommy8 | 5 | 11 | Some | |